Thursday, January 07, 2010

A new online Egyptology magazine?

Is there room in the world of Egyptology for an online magazine written by talented amateur Egyptologists, Egyptology society members, undergraduates and informal students? Kate Phizackerley (www.kv64.info) and I are doing market research into the possibility of setting one up.

Kate and I both receive articles for review for both popular and academic publication, and are often impressed by some of the quality of the amateur writing. Similarly, I have lectured at a number of UK Egyptology socieities where I have been impressed at the number of society members who have done research so detailed that they are more than qualified to lecture at their societies themselves (and attract sizeable and well informed audiences when they do so). It has become quite clear that there are many talented researchers who have done a lot of work into areas of particular interest, have some excellent content and ideas to impart, but who are unlikely to get published due to a lack of formal qualifications in the subject. That seems a shame.

So, in a chilly pub in London a few weeks ago, Kate and I discussed the idea of setting up a website which would give that research a platform. Our top level aim would be to try to attract pieces which are well researched and have a good reading list. We would not be looking for the sort of articles that appear in coffee-break magazines or on any amateur website that you can visit, and we would not want articles informed exclusively by Wikipedia or other informal (and unverifiable) sources. We are looking for good quality and well written contributions by writers who have real knowledge to impart and who have done their research using recognized sources. That doesn’t mean to say that we would want everything to be dull and lifeless – we would want the magazine to be entertaining. But we would like the contributions to be of a sufficiently high standard to inspire the confidence of readers who might like to reference the articles in their own research.

Does all this sound like something that would interest you as a writer or a reader? Would you like to contribute with articles, book reviews, exhibition reviews, photo-stories, and conference and lecture notes?

And do you have any ideas that might help us to narrow down the end product? We are only in the early stages of the thinking at the moment so any feedback would be very welcome. We will keep anyone who emails/comments updated on our progress as we decide if/how to proceed.

All responses will be valued.

To see more details, including an overview of how the magazine would operate in practical terms, please see Kate's comprehensive post:
http://www.kv64.info/2010/01/support-for-ancient-egypt-magazine.html


Kindest regards
Andie Byrnes



9 comments:

Chuck Jones said...

This is a great idea. I'll be happy to do what I can to support it.

I hope you intend to use one of the well constructed journal software packages such as The Public Knowledge Project's Open Journal System. It looks like it would serve your purposes extremely well.

-Chuck Jones-

Kate Phizackerley said...

Chuck,

That's already helpful. We'd rejected several platforms and WordPress was the only name left in the frame. I'll definitely audition Open Journal System as it has built-in support for editions and the online submission of articles.

Cheers
Kate

Andie said...

Thanks very much for all the emails so far - please keep the comments and emails coming. Andie.

Stan said...

Excellent idea!!!

Scrabcake said...

I'd want to write for that!
How would you handle peer reviewing, though. Would you bother with that sort of thing?

Unknown said...

I'd love to do this! I actually studied Egyptology for a semester but decided to put it off until grad school...I'm still kicking myself about it.

Kate Phizackerley said...

Thank you Samantha and Scrabcake. People interested in writing is the essential ingredient right now.

Please don't be offended if we don't get back to you immediately. We know that many people may only visit our blogs once a week so we'll give it time for people to comment or email us. Then Andie and I need to get together to talk about what we want to do and agree whether we have enough support to go ahead. I suspect it could be towards the end of the month before we are able to announce our intentions.

In answer to your question about reviews, at outset reviewing will probably be down to Andie and I. That might expand/evolve over time if we get volunteers to help with the reviewing. I've not discussed it with Andie, but as we progress I'd like to increase the number of volunteers involved so that most people interested in helping have a role if they want one. For instance, we will need images to use in the articles. A volunteer (or volunteers) to spend time finding suitable images and getting permission from the photographer to use them would be a real asset, but it doesn’t require anybody with writing skills. Although our call at present is to writers, if people are interested in helping in other ways, we’d like to hear from them too.

Kate

Anonymous said...

Fantastic Idea!

Anonymous said...

I can always whip up an article for you, no problem, just let me know what you would like. A great idea.

Tass